Survey Note: Detailed Comparison of Planet Fitness and LA Fitness for 2025

 This detailed analysis compares Planet Fitness and LA Fitness, two prominent gym chains, to help you decide which is right for your fitness journey in 2025. Drawing from recent data and official sources, we’ll explore pricing, amenities, target audiences, and more, ensuring a comprehensive understanding for potential members.

Background and Context

The fitness industry in 2025 continues to see strong competition among gym chains, with Planet Fitness, founded in 1992, and LA Fitness, established in 1984, standing out. Planet Fitness operates over 2,700 locations globally, emphasizing a "Judgement Free Zone" for beginners, while LA Fitness, with over 700 clubs in the US, is known for its extensive facilities. This comparison, based on current information as of March 21, 2025, aims to address the needs of various fitness levels and budgets.

Membership Options and Pricing

Pricing is a key factor for many gym-goers. Here’s a breakdown based on recent data:

Gym	Membership Type	Monthly Cost	Annual Fee	Contract Details	Startup Fee
Planet Fitness	Classic	$15	None	No contract	None
Planet Fitness	PF Black Card	$29.99	$49	12-month commitment	$1
LA Fitness	Basic	$39.99	$59	Not specified	Not specified
LA Fitness	Premier	$49.99	$59	Not specified, includes guest	Not specified

• Planet Fitness is notably more affordable, with the Classic plan at $15/month offering unlimited access to your home club without a contract, making it flexible for casual users. The PF Black Card, at $29.99/month, includes perks like guest privileges and tanning, but requires a 12-month commitment and has a $49 annual fee.
• LA Fitness, on the other hand, starts at $39.99/month for Basic and $49.99/month for Premier, which includes a free guest per visit. Both plans have a $59 annual fee, and pricing may vary by location, requiring users to check locally for exact costs.

This pricing difference highlights Planet Fitness as a budget-friendly option, while LA Fitness’s higher cost reflects its broader amenities, which might be unexpected for users expecting similar pricing structures.

Amenities and Facilities

The amenities offered by each gym significantly influence the user experience:

• Planet Fitness:
  • Focuses on basic cardio and strength equipment, suitable for general fitness.
  • Offers the PF App with digital workouts, tracking, and guides, enhancing user engagement.
  • Black Card members enjoy additional perks like bringing a guest anytime, tanning beds, massage chairs, and hydromassage.
  • Most locations provide 24/7 access, which is convenient for those with flexible schedules.
  • Lacks group fitness classes, which might be a drawback for some users.
• LA Fitness:
  • Provides extensive equipment, including free weights and specialized machines, catering to serious fitness enthusiasts.
  • Offers a variety of group fitness classes, such as yoga, Zumba, and cycling, included with membership.
  • Additional amenities include saunas, steam rooms, spas, and at some locations, swimming pools and basketball courts.
  • Personal training is available for an additional fee, offering personalized support.
  • Access to all club locations nationwide, which is a significant perk for frequent travelers.

The contrast in amenities is notable: Planet Fitness’s focus on a welcoming, basic setup contrasts with LA Fitness’s comprehensive offerings, which might surprise users expecting similar facility levels.

Target Audience and Atmosphere

The target audience for each gym aligns with their offerings:

• Planet Fitness is marketed as a "Judgement Free Zone," making it ideal for beginners, casual gym-goers, and those who prefer a non-intimidating environment. Its affordability and focus on accessibility (e.g., 24/7 access) appeal to those new to fitness or on a tight budget.
• LA Fitness, with its extensive equipment and classes, caters to serious fitness enthusiasts, including those interested in strength training, group activities, and additional amenities like pools. However, its traditional gym atmosphere might feel intimidating for beginners.

This difference in atmosphere is crucial, as it affects user comfort and engagement, an aspect that might not be immediately obvious to those comparing gyms solely on price.

Comparison Table: Key Differences

To summarize the comparison, here’s a table highlighting key differences:

Aspect	Planet Fitness	LA Fitness
Pricing	Starts at $15/month, Black Card at $29.99	Starts at $39.99/month, Premier at $49.99
Equipment	Basic cardio and strength, limited free weights	Extensive, includes free weights and specialized machines
Classes	No group classes, basic training available	Wide range, e.g., yoga, Zumba, cycling
Additional Perks	Tanning, massage chairs (Black Card)	Saunas, pools, spas (varies by location)
Atmosphere	"Judgement Free Zone," beginner-friendly	Traditional, serious fitness focus
Access	24/7 at most locations	Access to all clubs, hours vary

This table helps visualize the trade-offs, such as Planet Fitness’s affordability versus LA Fitness’s comprehensive facilities.

Pros and Cons

To further aid decision-making, here are the pros and cons of each:

• Planet Fitness:
  • Pros: Affordable, non-intimidating, 24/7 access, Black Card perks.
  • Cons: Limited equipment variety, no group fitness classes, potential crowding at some locations.
• LA Fitness:
  • Pros: Extensive equipment, wide range of classes, additional amenities, nationwide access.
  • Cons: Higher fees, may feel intimidating for beginners, amenities vary by location.

These pros and cons highlight the trade-offs, with Planet Fitness offering simplicity and cost savings, while LA Fitness provides a more robust fitness experience.

Decision Guidance: Which Gym is Right for You?

Choosing between the two depends on your specific needs:

• If you’re a beginner or prefer affordability: Opt for Planet Fitness, especially if you value a non-intimidating environment and flexible access. The Classic plan at $15/month is a great entry point, and Black Card perks can enhance your experience if you’re willing to commit.
• If you’re a serious fitness enthusiast: LA Fitness is likely better, offering extensive equipment, group classes, and amenities like pools, which cater to a more advanced fitness routine. The higher cost might be justified by the variety.
• If budget is a concern: Clearly, Planet Fitness is more budget-friendly, but remember the annual fee for Black Card and potential location-based variations.
• If you value additional perks: LA Fitness offers saunas and pools, while Planet Fitness’s Black Card includes tanning and massage chairs, so consider what matters most to you.

Visiting both gyms, if possible, can help you gauge the atmosphere and facilities, ensuring a comfortable fit for your fitness goals.

In 2025, both Planet Fitness and LA Fitness offer valuable options, but they cater to different audiences. Planet Fitness is ideal for those seeking an affordable, beginner-friendly gym, while LA Fitness suits serious fitness enthusiasts looking for comprehensive amenities. Consider your budget, fitness level, and preferences to make the best choice, and remember that visiting both can provide a clearer picture of what suits you.